The Blogora: The Rhetoric Society of America

 

Looking Towards NCA in San Diego


Submitted by Jim Aune on November 16, 2008 - 12:10pm


(for Dana Cloud, in thanks for that conversation on Barry Brummett's porch, and for your general fortitude):

Marianne Moore's

"Nevertheless"

you've seen a strawberry
that's had a struggle; yet
was, where the fragments met,

a hedgehog or a star-
fish for the multitude
of seeds. What better food

than apple seeds - the fruit
within the fruit - locked in
like counter-curved twin

hazelnuts? Frost that kills
the little rubber-plant -
leaves of kok-sagyyz-stalks, can't

harm the roots; they still grow
in frozen ground. Once where
there was a prickley-pear -

leaf clinging to a barbed wire,
a root shot down to grow
in earth two feet below;

as carrots from mandrakes
or a ram's-horn root some-
times. Victory won't come

to me unless I go
to it; a grape tendril
ties a knot in knots till

knotted thirty times - so
the bound twig that's under-
gone and over-gone, can't stir.

The weak overcomes its
menace, the strong over-
comes itself. What is there

like fortitude! What sap
went through that little thread
to make the cherry red!

Submitted by Anonymous on November 19, 2008 - 12:56pm.

I am moved.

A gift for you from Engels:

In proof of this law we might have cited hundreds of other similar facts from nature as well as from human society. Thus, for example, the whole of Part IV of Marx's Capital — production of relative surplus-value — deals, in the field of co-operation, division of labour and manufacture, machinery and modern industry, with innumerable cases in which quantitative change alters the quality, and also qualitative change alters the quantity, of the things under consideration; in which therefore, to use the expression so hated by Herr Dühring, quantity is transformed into quality and vice versa. As for example the fact that the co-operation of a number of people, the fusion of many forces into one single force, creates, to use Marx's phrase, a "new power", which is essentially different from the sum of its separate forces.

--Dana

Submitted by rhosa (not verified) on November 16, 2008 - 9:03pm.
Submitted by Adria on November 17, 2008 - 10:53am.

I want to thank Dr. Cloud, Dr. Pezzullo, Dr. Simons, and the others who have given us the chance to recognize injustice and discrimination and to act for justice and equality. Predictably, this opportunity has often been met with vitriol. Sadly, we ignore our literature on social movements and our field's devotion to MLK, preferring to cling to comfort and rationalizations and our culture of convenience. So we swat at the gadflies in our midst and stridently denounce the hardships of inconvenience and conscience. Our ready embrace of the consumer identity and neglect of the worker and activist has landed us in a fine mess in so many ways that it may behoove us to remember the words of
Dr. King (and Plato's Aristophanes on love): "Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere"; "lamentably, it is an historical fact that privileged groups seldom give up their privileges voluntarily"; "We know through painful experience that freedom is never voluntarily given by the oppressor; it must be demanded by the oppressed"; "injustice must be exposed, with all the tension its exposure creates, to the light of human conscience and the air of national opinion before it can be cured"; "We must use time creatively, in the knowledge that the time is always ripe to do right" ("Letter from a Birmingham Jail"). We
have too often decided not to honor picket lines and fight for workers' rights over the past thirty years, and now we are poorer for it. We congratulate ourselves for voting and declare an historic victory for equality, while overlooking the inequality many still suffer. I thank my colleagues for giving us the opportunity at this inconvenient moment to practice our politics (whatever our positions) with pained awareness instead of blissful ignorance.

Kevin DeLuca
Kevin.DeLuca@utah.edu